Almond Mushroom, ABM · 2020 · Journal Article
Low relevanceDoes attention bias modification induce structural brain changes? A commentary on Abend et al. (2019).
Agaricus blazei
Key points
- The strength of research conclusions must follow from the strength of evidence
- In this commentary I raise several issues with a recent paper "Brain structure changes induced by attention bias modification training" (Abend et al., 2019)
- I follow the paper's five highlights to discuss; the absence of discussion of negative ABM results, the low power of the study itself
- Centrally, I raise the concern that the conclusions rest all their weight on a single statistically significant group x time interaction form brain-wide analysis
- Most importantly, this test is not internally consistent following statcheck
- The reported result requires checking, and potentially a correction that would shift the results entirely
Metadata-grounded summary
Citation abstract
The strength of research conclusions must follow from the strength of evidence. In this commentary I raise several issues with a recent paper "Brain structure changes induced by attention bias modification training" (Abend et al., 2019). I follow the paper's five highlights to discuss; the absence of discussion of negative ABM results, the low power of the study itself. Centrally, I raise the concern that the conclusions rest all their weight on a single statistically significant group x time interaction form brain-wide analysis. Most importantly, this test is not internally consistent following statcheck. The reported result requires checking, and potentially a correction that would shift the results entirely.
Citation
Parsons S (2020). Does attention bias modification induce structural brain changes? A commentary on Abend et al. (2019). Biological psychology https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2020.107866 PMID: 32087312
Open citation